Millcreek Manor

5535 PEACH STREET, ERIE, Pennsylvania 16509

Phone: (814) 868-7395

4/5Above Average

Verified Data

Sources: CMS Care CompareUpdated: April 2026How we compile →

Facility Report Card

Overall CMS rating is 4/5 stars — "Above Average."
Total nurse staffing of 4.8 hrs/resident/day is well above the national average (~3.8).
RN staffing is strong at 1.10 hours per resident per day.
Has received 1 fine totaling $100,240 — review the penalties section for details.
27 deficiencies recorded, including 1 severe.

CMS Star Ratings

Overall

Above Average

Health Inspection

Average

Staffing

Much Above Average

Quality Measures

Average

Staffing Data

Total Nurse Staffing (hrs/resident/day)	4.84
RN Staffing (hrs/resident/day)	1.10
Staff Turnover Rate	45.1%
Staffing Star Rating

Penalties & Fines

Fines

Total Fine Amount

$100,240

Deficiencies

Severe Deficiencies

Facility Details

Certified Beds	144
Average Residents/Day	137.3
Ownership Type	Non profit - Corporation
Provider Type	Medicare and Medicaid
Continuing Care Community	No
Resident & Family Council	Resident
Ownership Changed (12 mo)	No
Special Focus Status	None
CMS Certification #	396072

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the overall rating of Millcreek Manor?

Millcreek Manor has an overall CMS rating of 4 out of 5 stars, which is considered "Above Average." This composite score reflects health inspections, staffing levels, and quality measures as reported by CMS Care Compare.

How many beds does Millcreek Manor have?

Millcreek Manor is a large facility with 144 certified beds and an average of 137.3 residents per day. It is located in ERIE, Pennsylvania.

What is the staffing level at Millcreek Manor?

Millcreek Manor provides 4.84 total nurse staffing hours per resident per day, which is above the national average. Registered Nurse (RN) hours are 1.10 per resident per day. The total nursing staff turnover rate is 45.1%.

Has Millcreek Manor received any fines or penalties?

Yes, Millcreek Manor has received 1 fine totaling $100,240 and 1 total penalty. The facility has 27 recorded deficiencies, including 1 severe.

What type of ownership is Millcreek Manor?

Millcreek Manor is classified as "Non profit - Corporation" by CMS.

Is Millcreek Manor Medicare or Medicaid certified?

Millcreek Manor is certified as "Medicare and Medicaid" by CMS. This means it participates in Medicare and Medicaid programs and must meet federal quality standards.

Was this data helpful?